The Miniaturist by Jessie Burton

A couple of years ago I made a resolution to occasionally buy books that I knew nothing about. I know, I shouldn’t strain myself, right? Anyway, the point was to seek out books that I hadn’t read reviews of; by an author that was new to me; and that didn’t have any ‘hype’. If you hang around book blogs, it’s harder than it sounds (but it’s okay, I’m coping). This is how I came across The Miniaturist by Jessie Burton.

The testimonials by S. J. Watson, Hannah Kent and Deborah Moggach (who wrote the very interesting book, Tulip Fever) on the cover of the The Miniaturist were enough to prompt me to pick it up – such an odd mix of authors singing its praises.

The story is set in Amsterdam, in 1686. The city is ruled by the sea and Calvinist burgomasters (both grim and ever-threatening), and its people shun ostentatious displays – meals of cold herrings and bread while their sugar is eaten in secret; plain woolen clothes lined with the finest furs and silks.

“Founded on risk, Amsterdam now craves certainty, a neat passage through life, guarding the comfort of its money with dull obedience.”

Eighteen-year-old  Petronella (Nella) Oortman arrives at the grand house of her new husband, the wealthy merchant Johannes Brandt. The marriage is a strategic arrangement, providing wealth for Nella and a well-respected family name for Brandt. However Nella’s new life in Amsterdam comes with surprises – the household is run by Johannes’s bitter sister, Marin; Johannes does not come to Nella’s room at night, as her mother explained he would; and Nella receives an odd wedding gift from her new husband – a perfect miniature replica of their home, the rooms empty, with Nella charged to furnish them. And that’s when things start to get very odd…

Firstly, I’ll get my peeves out of the way – Nella (and some of the dialogue) is altogether too modern. I’m not convinced that a girl from the country would have the maturity and self-assurance to handle what comes to her. Is Burton deliberately toying with her readers, casting Nella as a worldly 17th century feminist?! Perhaps.

Then there’s the supernatural element of the plot which admittedly, I didn’t love. Burton uses it to tie up loose ends and I think in doing so she asks a little too much of her audience. But let your eyes skip ahead to my rating – four stars – because there was something captivating about this story and amongst the brash plot twists, are some utterly beautiful passages.

“The funeral is supposed to be a quiet affair, for the deceased had no friends. But words are water in Amsterdam, they flood your ears and set the rot, and the church’s east corner is crowded.”

The historical detail is rich and meticulous –

“Nella begins to scale the ladder, seeking out the sugar. It feels as if she is climbing through her husband’s life… Past bolts of Coromandel and Bengal silk, cloves, mace and nutmeg in crates marked Molucca, pepper labelled from Malabar, peels of Ceylonese cinnamon… Past Delft plates, casks of wine…, boxes of vermilion and cochineal, mercury for mirrors and the syphilis, Persian trinkets cast in gold and silver… Here is real life, she thinks, out of breath and giddy. Here is where true adventures come to land.”

The theme of being ‘trapped’ in a gilded cage is played out on many levels – literally with Nella’s pet parrot, Peebo, being banished by Marin to the kitchen; Marin’s secret life (exotic treasures and fur-lined corsets); Johannes’s man-servant, Otto, whom he rescued from slavery, only to become an object of curiosity in puritan Amsterdam; and of course Nella herself, trapped in a loveless marriage. The theme is such that the more you look, the more you find – I could provide a dozen more examples but that would be giving the story away.

4/5  I forgive Burton for some obvious missteps because the last few chapters were just wonderful. I *might* have even had a little cry.

Cornelia makes ‘olie-koeck’ –

“…the fried crust breaks apart under Nella’s teeth, releasing the perfect blnd of almond, ginger, clove and apple.”

Olie-koeck translates literally as ‘oil-cake’ – that might not sound so good except that we know them best as doughnuts. The Netherlands Bakery Museum describes the history of olie-koeck.





13 responses

  1. Oddly enough, this was THE book earlier this year here in the US (maybe around May). It was so hyped that it became something I wanted to avoid. I still have my review copy sitting on my shelf. I will have to re-evaluate my stance. As for the supernatural, I either like it in full force or not at all. So we’ll see how that works for me.

    • So weird how different books get hyped in different places. After I finished it I looked at some reviews and was very surprised to see someone say “After all the hype…” It was in the new release section of my local bookshop but not prominently so and when I mentioned I’d bought it to some reading friends, none of them had heard of it.

      The super-natural element will probably piss you off – Burton uses it as a tool but it’s by no means the major plot point. As I said, there were some major flaws in the way the story and characters were constructed but I read it on holiday and found it very compelling. I think I’ll have to hunt down interviews with the author – fascinated to know whether she deliberately tried to make Nella a stealth feminist.

    • I did too – not the sort of thing I’d ordinarily pick up (because of the supernatural element) but my personal challenge was to find something different – and I was rewarded!

  2. I started listening to this novel being read on BBC Radio 4 and thought maybe I should stop listening and read the whole novel! Unfortunately one of the reviews on Amazon had a huge spoiler in the opening sentence so it wasn’t to be… So disappointing. I reported the review but don’t know if it’s been removed.
    Anyway, does it win the most beautiful cover of the year??? 🙂

  3. Pingback: Six Degrees of Separation – from Year of Wonders to The Muse | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  4. Pingback: Sample Saturday – a tulip, a waitress, and a painting | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  5. Pingback: The Muse by Jessie Burton | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  6. Pingback: October Rewind | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  7. Pingback: Bookish (and not so bookish) Thoughts | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  8. Pingback: Bookish (and not so bookish) Thoughts | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  9. Pingback: The Miniaturist – Book vs. TV Series | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  10. Pingback: Three short reviews | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.