Book vs. Film: The Mysteries of Pittsburgh

book vs film mysteries of pittsburgh

Book.

  • Because the movie casting was just wrong, wrong, wrong. Particularly Cleveland. And where the hell was the (pivotal) character of Arthur?
  • Book had a subtle but distinct sense of place. Movie – not so.
  • The ‘themes’ in the book (notably sexuality) are carefully played out. In the movie, they are as subtle as a drag queen’s eye shadow.

See my review of The Mysteries of Pittsburgh by Michael Chabon here.

Top Ten Tuesday – Book to Movie Adaptations

Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly feature created and hosted by The Broke and the Bookish. Each week a new ‘top ten’ challenge is posted – anyone can join in. This week’s topic is a freebie so I’ve picked my top ten book to movie adaptations.

I’m the person that won’t see the film unless I’ve read the book. And most often I prefer the book (or perhaps I simply prefer the experience of reading rather than watching a film?!). But in some cases, films are PERFECT translations of the book, the characters and scenes unfolding just as you imagined. And sometimes a film not only does a book justice but makes it better. Yes, really. My top ten book to movie adaptations are the books that I think rocketed into awesomeness thanks to a fabulous film…

1. A Room with a View – a Merchant Ivory masterpiece.

2. Gone with the Wind – Vivien Leigh IS Scarlett.

3. Anne of Green Gables – perfection. Continue reading

Book vs Film: Feast of Love

Book. By a whisker.

  • The book has an extra layer of detail. Important in understanding the motives of some characters.
  • Hey filmmakers, don’t mess with Baxter’s intriguing beginning and sublime conclusion.
  • The actors in the film were all slightly too good-looking (especially Bradley, played by Greg Kinnear) to fit with Baxter’s story.
  • Winning film moment though – the ‘falling in love’ scenes between Katherine and Jenny, and Oscar and Chloe.

The Feast of Love by Charles Baxter.